View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0002963CCdcielGeneralpublic26-11-07 12:07
ReporterPavol Gajdos Assigned To 
PriorityhighSeveritymajorReproducibilitysometimes
Status newResolutionopen 
Summary0002963: Simbad server down
DescriptionCDS centrum in Strasbourg is currently down due to a cybersecurity incident. Therefore, the default Simbad mirror (https://simbad.cds.unistra.fr/simbad/) is not available. And "search online" in CCDCiel doesn't work.
It'll be useful to add the possibility of choosing a different Simbad mirror: https://simbad.harvard.edu/.
Steps To ReproduceSearch target online - e.g. in "GoTo" or in Sequence.
TagsNo tags attached.

Activities

Patrick Chevalley

26-11-02 11:26

administrator   ~0009987

I look at that but the problem is CCDciel do not use Simbad directly, it use the CDS Sesame solver that search in Simbad, NED and Vizier to return an easy to parse XML response.
And I cannot find a Sesame mirror or a way to make the Simbad mirror to send a similar XML format.

Pavol Gajdos

26-11-02 13:12

reporter   ~0009988

I found a web form on the CFA web page: https://vizier.cfa.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/Sesame. But I don't know if there is an API for this mirror.
An alternative solution will be to query Simbad directly using the TAP service.

Patrick Chevalley

26-11-03 09:10

administrator   ~0009989

Yes I have this URL in CdC search function, it is https://vizier.cfa.harvard.edu/viz-bin/nph-sesame
But it give an error 502, probably because they cut the access to the server.

More generally there is no reason the same php code that is unsafe at Strasbourg is safe at Harvard.
Maybe it is more easy to isolate a mirror server to let it running with unsafe code and this is why we still have access to https://simbad.cfa.harvard.edu
But this can change at any time, so I will not take too much time with that.

The backup solution is simply a copy/past of the coordinates from somewhere we find the object of interest.

Pavol Gajdos

26-11-07 08:52

reporter   ~0009990

There is a new Sesame mirror. It works for me.

IDIA server (South Africa) @ https://vizier.idia.ac.za/viz-bin/Sesame

API @ https://vizier.idia.ac.za/viz-bin/nph-sesame/{option}?{object}

eg: https://vizier.idia.ac.za/viz-bin/nph-sesame/-ox/?vega

Patrick Chevalley

26-11-07 12:07

administrator   ~0009991

Thank you.
This help me to find why the mirror where not working with Skychart and CCDciel.

The reason is each mirror only accept a subset of the parameters available with the CDS version.
The IDIA server make me search in this direction because it not accept the parameter to select the source (Simbad,Vizier,NED), and Harvard accept it but it is ignored. Also each mirror have different requirement for the name encoding.
Maybe this options are possible with different syntax, but this is not documented, the documentation link send the the unavailable CDS.
By constructing the URL specifically for each server by try and error I can finally make it to work.

I add the option to select the mirror in the first preferences page.
You need to select Harvard if you also need the star magnitude, IDIA do not return them, but both work for the coordinates.

This is in version 0.9.97-4259 : https://vega.ap-i.net/pub/ccdciel/daily_build/

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
26-10-29 19:13 Pavol Gajdos New Issue
26-11-02 11:26 Patrick Chevalley Note Added: 0009987
26-11-02 13:12 Pavol Gajdos Note Added: 0009988
26-11-03 09:10 Patrick Chevalley Note Added: 0009989
26-11-07 08:52 Pavol Gajdos Note Added: 0009990
26-11-07 12:07 Patrick Chevalley Note Added: 0009991