View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0001146SkyChart1-Softwarepublic14-03-29 17:55
ReporterPepe Chambó Assigned ToPatrick Chevalley  
PrioritynormalSeveritymajorReproducibilityalways
Status closedResolutionfixed 
Platformx86OSWindowsOS VersionXP
Product Version3.6 
Target Version3.10Fixed in Version3.9 SVN 
Summary0001146: Comet PANSTARRS jump coordinates
DescriptionThe comet PANSTARRS (and others I supose) change your location erroneously.
Steps To ReproduceShow comet PANSTARRS on 15-March-2013 and then step 1 day to 16-March-2013...
TagsNo tags attached.

Activities

Patrick Chevalley

13-03-07 19:07

administrator   ~0002466

I not understand your problem description.

Can you provide detailed steps to reproduce the problem, if possible starting with the default configuration.
Also join screenshot of the problem.

Pepe Chambó

13-03-08 12:38

reporter  

2011L4_20130313.png (138,626 bytes)   
2011L4_20130313.png (138,626 bytes)   

Pepe Chambó

13-03-08 12:39

reporter  

2011L4_20130314.png (140,251 bytes)   
2011L4_20130314.png (140,251 bytes)   

Pepe Chambó

13-03-08 12:39

reporter  

2011L4_20130315.png (141,751 bytes)   
2011L4_20130315.png (141,751 bytes)   

Pepe Chambó

13-03-08 12:39

reporter  

2011L4_20130316.png (140,942 bytes)   
2011L4_20130316.png (140,942 bytes)   

Pepe Chambó

13-03-08 12:40

reporter  

2011L4_20130317.png (139,617 bytes)   
2011L4_20130317.png (139,617 bytes)   

Pepe Chambó

13-03-08 12:40

reporter  

2011L4_20130318.png (139,774 bytes)   
2011L4_20130318.png (139,774 bytes)   

Pepe Chambó

13-03-08 12:43

reporter   ~0002467

Hi Patrick.

The problem is that after March 15 the comet inexplicably jumps to another part of the sky (seems some days before your theoric orbit).

Patrick Chevalley

13-03-08 14:53

administrator   ~0002468

OK, I see it.

You probably have different element set for this comet and one is totally wrong.
You can load elements valid for different date and Skychart search the elements database to use the element set for the current date.
Probably it switch from two set between the 15 and 16.

To know which elements are used, click on the comet to display the detailed information.
If using the latest available MPC it should be: ref: 5/2013-03-04

But I think that all your elements are obsolete because even on your better map from 13 to 15, the comet is off it's real position by about 2 degrees.

Please try the following to cleanup your element database:
- open the menu Setup / Solar system / Comet / Data maintenance
- click the Delete button in the box "Quickly delete all data related to comets"
- click tab "Load MPC file"
- click button Download

Pepe Chambó

13-03-11 13:38

reporter   ~0002469

Thanks a lot Patrick!
Exactly, my error was I had not updated my database, I'm sorry.
Anyway, I think could suggest introduce a warning message at starting when comets database is "n" days without actualize.
Regards.

Patrick Chevalley

13-03-12 08:27

administrator   ~0002471

I agree to add a warning message.

Patrick Chevalley

13-03-29 15:45

administrator   ~0002487

Revision 2481 show a warning if the elements are more than six month old:
http://sourceforge.net/p/skychart/code/2481/

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
13-03-07 18:15 Pepe Chambó New Issue
13-03-07 19:07 Patrick Chevalley Note Added: 0002466
13-03-07 19:07 Patrick Chevalley Assigned To => Patrick Chevalley
13-03-07 19:07 Patrick Chevalley Status new => feedback
13-03-08 12:38 Pepe Chambó File Added: 2011L4_20130313.png
13-03-08 12:39 Pepe Chambó File Added: 2011L4_20130314.png
13-03-08 12:39 Pepe Chambó File Added: 2011L4_20130315.png
13-03-08 12:39 Pepe Chambó File Added: 2011L4_20130316.png
13-03-08 12:40 Pepe Chambó File Added: 2011L4_20130317.png
13-03-08 12:40 Pepe Chambó File Added: 2011L4_20130318.png
13-03-08 12:43 Pepe Chambó Note Added: 0002467
13-03-08 12:43 Pepe Chambó Status feedback => assigned
13-03-08 14:53 Patrick Chevalley Note Added: 0002468
13-03-08 14:53 Patrick Chevalley Status assigned => feedback
13-03-11 13:38 Pepe Chambó Note Added: 0002469
13-03-11 13:38 Pepe Chambó Status feedback => assigned
13-03-12 08:27 Patrick Chevalley Note Added: 0002471
13-03-12 08:27 Patrick Chevalley Priority urgent => normal
13-03-12 08:27 Patrick Chevalley Target Version 0.3.0 => 3.10
13-03-29 15:45 Patrick Chevalley Note Added: 0002487
13-03-29 15:45 Patrick Chevalley Status assigned => resolved
13-03-29 15:45 Patrick Chevalley Resolution open => fixed
13-03-29 15:45 Patrick Chevalley Fixed in Version 0.3.0 => 3.9 SVN
14-03-29 17:55 Patrick Chevalley Status resolved => closed